Deconstructing a Green Claim

Ten PCs = One Car? Here's how Microsoft interprets and derives this oft-repeated factoid.

What Microsoft Says
"Every 10 PCs with CRTs migrated to Windows Vista and configured to use Power Management is equivalent to taking one car off the road in terms of greenhouse gasses."

Back Story
In an era of alarming TV footage of melting glaciers and more personally alarming prices at the gas pump, both consumers and business buyers are citing environmental considerations and energy costs in their purchasing decisions. Seizing on this green mood, Microsoft has taken to repeating the "10-PCs-to-one-car" factoid in its pitch for Windows Vista adoption. This particular claim appears on a Microsoft Web site called "Windows Vista for the Enterprise/Windows Vista Facts"; Brad Brooks, corporate vice president for Microsoft's Online Services and Windows Business Group, cited the same formula in a May webcast. The foundation for the statement is contained in Microsoft's October 2006 white paper, "Windows Vista Energy Conservation."

Microsoft's Assumptions

  • The per-PC carbon dioxide reductions are derived by comparing Windows Vista against Windows Vista. In one case, the Windows Vista system is left running all the time. In the other case, it's running 10 hours per day, five days per week, and otherwise is in sleep mode. These comparisons do not involve Windows XP or any other operating system.
  • Calculations were based on Windows Vista running on a "typical" Pentium 4 with a 17-inch CRT monitor or a 17-inch LCD monitor.
  • Microsoft used a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency estimate that generating 1 kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity in the United States results in 1.55 pounds of carbon dioxide emissions. Under Microsoft's model, the CRT system saves 760.14 kWh per year, while the LCD systems saves 597.52 kWh per year.
  • An EPA estimate puts the average carbon dioxide emissions of a car at 11,560 pounds per year.
Figure 1
[Click on image for larger view.]

Is It True?
In a strict sense, the statement is supportable. It's the implications that get messy.

For one thing, the assumptions are based on CRT and LCD systems in an era when laptop sales are overtaking PC sales.

Presumably the savings aren't as dramatic on laptops, which tend to have much lower power requirements. Laptop figures aren't included in the white paper.

By using the phrase "migrated to Windows Vista" in the marketing message, the implication is that these savings are measured against Windows XP. As the assumption section shows, Windows XP is not involved in the calculations in any way. In other words, there may be a legitimate savings, but it is not measured by this paper.

Windows Vista has also been criticized as being more power hungry than Windows XP because of the significant delta in hardware requirements for Windows Vista when compared with Windows XP.

As often happens, the marketing message has spun away from the conditional facts that support it. Within the white paper, the statement is "Ten of these [Windows Vista] PCs left on when not in use results in the equivalent of one more car on the road in terms of greenhouse gas contribution annually."

Analysis by Scott Bekker/RCP Staff

About the Author

Scott Bekker is editor in chief of Redmond Channel Partner magazine.


  • RAMBleed Side-Channel Attack Method Disclosed by Researchers

    Academic researchers this week published information about another side-channel attack method, called "RAMBleed," that can expose information from memory chips, including encryption key information.

  • Penguin

    Windows 10 Preview Build 18917 Shows Off New Linux Integration

    Microsoft's latest Windows 10 "fast-ring" preview release is showcasing a coming Delivery Optimization enhancement, along with the ability to try the newly emerged Windows Subsystem for Linux version 2.

  • Customizing Microsoft Office 365

    While the overall look and feel of Office 365 is pretty standard across organizations, there are several ways to personalize it and make it fit better with your company's specific needs.

  • Microsoft 365 Business Tenants Getting Conditional Access and Trouble-Ticket Features

    Microsoft added its conditional access security service to Microsoft 365 Business subscriptions, according to a Wednesday announcement, and it also added new trouble-ticket features for Microsoft 365 administrators.

comments powered by Disqus

Office 365 Watch

Sign up for our newsletter.

Terms and Privacy Policy consent

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.