Microsoft Wins First Scrimmage Against Google in Employee Lawsuit
Late last week in Seattle, Superior Court Judge Steven Gonzalez issued a temporary
restraining order preventing Google from asking its intended head of China operations,
former Microsoft employee Kai-Fu Lee, from doing anything that could be seen
as competing with Microsoft.
The judge also ruled that Lee is prevented from sharing any trade secrets with
Google. The order is good through Sept 6., when a motion for an injunction is
scheduled to be heard. Microsoft filed the lawsuit against Lee and Google on
The order may not prevent Lee from taking his post, as Google said it does
not feel Kai-Fu Lee's new position is competitive with his Microsoft tenure.
"While we don't believe a [temporary restraining order] is necessary, we're
gratified that the judge recognized that all Google and Dr. Lee have to do is
avoid having Dr. Lee do anything competitive with what he did at Microsoft.
As we have said all along, we have no intention of having him do that,"
Nicole Wong, Google associate general counsel, commented in a released statement.
"The judge also ordered Microsoft to be more specific in identifying the
matters that Dr. Lee worked on at Microsoft that they claim are competitive
with what he will do at Google. We will be looking for clarification when Microsoft
complies with the judge's order."
As evident by the lawsuit, Microsoft sees the situation differently. "As
a senior executive, Dr. Lee has direct knowledge of Microsoft's trade secrets
concerning search technologies and China business strategies," it commented
when it announced the lawsuit. "He has accepted a position focused on the
same set of technologies and strategies for a director competitor in egregious
violation of his explicit contractual obligations."
Lee was hired to run Microsoft's research and development labs in China in
1999, and was most recently head working for the company on speech recognition
technology. He signed the non-compete agreement in 2000, reports state.
Trial has been set for January 9.
Becky Nagel is the vice president of Web & Digital Strategy for 1105's Converge360 Group, where she oversees the front-end Web team and deals with all aspects of digital projects at the company, including launching and running the group's popular virtual summit and Coffee talk series . She an experienced tech journalist (20 years), and before her current position, was the editorial director of the group's sites. A few years ago she gave a talk at a leading technical publishers conference about how changes in Web browser technology would impact online advertising for publishers. Follow her on twitter @beckynagel.