News

Gartner: ECMA Standardization of C# to Have Little Effect on Java

An analyst at Gartner this week says the ECMA approval as standards of Microsoft's C# programming language and the Common Language Infrastructure that C# runs on will have little effect on Java.

"ECMA's approval does little to give C# the key characteristic of Java -— its ability to operate on all computing platforms," according to the bulletin based on research by David Smith, a Gartner analyst for Internet strategies.

Microsoft announced last week the ECMA approval, which the company portrays as a "a milestone in the industry’s standardization efforts around XML Web services as well as programming language innovation." The company also emphasized industry support for C# and the Common Language Infrastructure (CLI) in the form of contributions to the specification from Hewlett-Packard, IBM Corp., Intel Corp. and Netscape Communications Corp.

CLI is a subset of the .NET Framework, which Microsoft will launch in February. CLI includes the Common Language Runtime and other parts of the .NET platform.

The ECMA ratification is a black eye for Sun, which submitted Java to the ECMA then withdrew it last year. Microsoft submitted C# and CLI to ECMA in October 2000.

Microsoft positions C# as providing .NET developers with many of the benefits of the Java language, but Gartner expects Microsoft to try to use C# and its .NET Framework "to dampen Java's growing critical mass among developers."

"Accordingly, the ECMA approval represents a victory of sorts for Microsoft," Gartner's Smith says. "In a small way, Microsoft has shown that it has gone further to make C# a language that's 'open' to all developers. For most people, though, Java remains open enough."

Smith argues that the bigger issue is whether .NET will run on platforms other than Windows.

" Gartner sees little business incentive for Microsoft to want to promote all of .NET on alternate platforms," Smith notes. "As a result, Gartner predicts little or no impact on Java."

About the Author

Scott Bekker is editor in chief of Redmond Channel Partner magazine.

Featured

  • Weird Blue Tunnel Graphic

    Microsoft Goes Deep on 'Solorigate' Secondary Attack Methods

    Microsoft on Wednesday published an analysis of the second-stage "Solorigate" attack methods used by an advanced persistent threat (APT) attack group.

  • Microsoft Talks Teams and SharePoint at Modern Workplace Event

    It's a hybrid world, but remote work is here to stay, according to Microsoft's Teams and SharePoint head Jeff Teper.

  • Malwarebytes Affirms Other APT Attack Methods Used Besides 'Solorigate'

    Security solutions company Malwarebytes affirmed on Monday that alternative methods besides tainted SolarWinds Orion software were used in the recent "Solorigate" advanced persistent threat (APT) attacks.

  • How To Fix the Hyper-V Read Only Disk Problem

    DOS might seem like a relic now, but sometimes it's the only way to fix a problem that Windows seems ill-equipped to deal with -- like this one.

comments powered by Disqus