News

Court of Appeals Denies Microsoft's Stay Request

The U.S. Court of Appeals on Friday denied Microsoft Corp.'s request to delay sending its case back to the District Court.

Microsoft had wanted the case put on hold until the Supreme Court ruled on its request for an appeal. The Supreme Court has not decided yet whether it should take up the case.

The Appeals Court in late June overturned the order to break Microsoft into two companies, but let stand the legal findings that Microsoft abused a monopoly position in the client operating system market.

Microsoft's appeal to the Supreme Court hinges on the Appeals Court's strong condemnation of Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson's conduct during the original antitrust hearings. In its June opinion, the Appeals Court particularly objected to Jackson's having granted embargoed interviews to journalists before the case was finished.

In its Supreme Court appeal, Microsoft argues the Appeals Court should have thrown out Jackson's Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in the case because both legal judgments were issued after the secret interviews had begun.

"It appears that Microsoft has misconstrued our opinion, particularly with respect to what would have been required to justify vacating the district court's findings of fact and conclusions of law as a remedy for the violation of 28 U.S.C.," the court wrote Friday in denying the stay.

The Appeals Court judges wrote that Microsoft failed to demonstrate how it would be harmed if the district court started its rehearing before the Supreme Court decided on Microsoft's appeals petition.

The Department of Justice's response brief to the Supreme Court argues that the high court should not accept the case in a limited fashion now because the entire case is likely to wind up there eventually.

About the Author

Scott Bekker is editor in chief of Redmond Channel Partner magazine.

Featured

  • Microsoft Endpoint Manager Improvements Highlighted at Ignite

    Improvements in the Microsoft Endpoint Manager (MEM) management solution were part of Tuesday's Microsoft Ignite online event.

  • Green City Illustration

    Microsoft Ignite 2020 Reaction, Part 1: A New Normal for Tech Conferences

    Something about Satya Nadella's opening keynote makes Brien wonder if Microsoft thinks we'd all be better off doing everything -- including conferences like Ignite -- remotely, even after the pandemic is over.

  • Microsoft Ignite: Azure Advances Across Five Frontiers

    To kick off the Microsoft Ignite virtual conference, CEO Satya Nadella made a bold claim about the public cloud with the second-largest market share behind Amazon.

  • Microsoft Buying Games Maker ZeniMax Media for $7.5 Billion

    Microsoft is buying ZeniMax Media, parent company of Bethesda Softworks and other game-maker affiliates, for $7.5 billion in cash.

comments powered by Disqus