Microsoft Petitions Appeals Court for Rehearing

Even as the government tries to hurry the antitrust case back into U.S. District Court, Microsoft Corp. moved to keep the action in the U.S. Court of Appeals for a little while longer.

This week, Microsoft filed for a rehearing on the issue of commingling from the Appeals Court's decision of June 28. In that decision, the Appeals Court found that Microsoft had abused its monopoly power, but sent the case back to the District Court for a new remedy.

The decision invalidated Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson's order to split the company into an operating system company and an applications company. The appeals court also ordered that a different judge preside over the remedy phase.

Microsoft wants a hearing on one of Jackson's earlier finding of fact, which the appellate court accepted, that Microsoft commingled Windows 98 and Internet Explorer code and that the commingling violated the Sherman Antitrust Act.

At issue are Internet Explorer and Windows 98.

Microsoft argues that the district court's definition of commingling would be mixing Web browsing code with other operating system code for no technical reason. The implication is that the reason would be to squelch competition.

Microsoft contends the evidence presented in court was insufficient to outweigh testimony from Microsoft Group Vice President Jim Allchin that there were technical reasons, such as operating system performance and development efficiency, that Internet Explorer and other parts of the operating system share code for similar functions.

Last week, the government asked the appeals court to put the case on a fast track in the District Court due to the rapid pace of the high-tech industry and the broad impact of the case.

Related Articles:
DOJ Wants Fast Track; New Mexico Settles
Microsoft Revises OEM Licensing Agreements

About the Author

Scott Bekker is editor in chief of Redmond Channel Partner magazine.


  • Old Stone Wall Graphic

    Microsoft Addressing 36 Vulnerabilities in December Security Patch Release

    Microsoft on Tuesday delivered its December bundle of security patches, which affect Windows, Internet Explorer, Office, Skype for Business, SQL Server and Visual Studio.

  • Microsoft Nudging Out Classic SharePoint Blogs

    So-called "classic" blogs used by SharePoint Online subscribers are on their way toward "retirement," according to Dec. 4 Microsoft Message Center post.

  • Datacenters in Space: OrbitsEdge Partners with HPE

    A Florida-based startup is partnering with Hewlett Packard Enterprise in a deal that gives new meaning to the "edge" in edge computing.

  • Windows 10 Hyper-V vs. Windows Server Hyper-V: Which Platform for Which Workloads?

    The differences between these two Hyper-V versions are pretty significant, depending on what you plan to use them for. Here's a quick rundown of each platform, from their features to licensing quirks to intended use cases.

comments powered by Disqus

Office 365 Watch

Sign up for our newsletter.

Terms and Privacy Policy consent

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.