Reader Feedback Friday: Readers Control the Microsoft Robot

Last week, we gave you control of the Microsoft robot, and you grabbed the command right out of our hands. What resulted were some of the best e-mails we've ever had.

First up was David, who created a couple of robots of his own:

"The Microsoft robot could be the Swiss army knife of robots. It could store your music collection, balance your checkbook and do your online Christmas shopping for you. It would probably be squat and boxy but easy for everyone to learn and use, but, like children, you have to worry about them spreading viruses on the playground.

"The Mac OS robot would be sleek and sophisticated, if just a little arrogant. It would edit your home videos and clean up your digital photos all while poking fun at the boring, old Microsoft robot. It would be more expensive than the Microsoft robot and claim to be able to do everything the Microsoft robot can -- and do it better.

"The Linux robot would be built from any parts available, and therefore could appear as anything from an insect to a racecar to a Microsoft robot with a knowing smirk on its face. It would be the most highly configurable of all of the robots, with huge numbers of components available, many of which work mostly as advertised if the owner is willing to spend the time to get them configured properly. It comes with a preinstalled flamethrower triggered by an RTM sensor."

We'll take the Linux robot, please (for the flamethrower, of course), although the Mac OS robot sounds like the most fun to hang around.

Frequent contributor Jon was up next, with a few shots at Vista:

"I want my Microsoft robot to write the successor for Windows XP. If I hadn't taken my workplace violence training, I would also like it to strangle whoever thought of Vista."

Wait...we have to stop here for a second. Workplace violence training? We're brimming with questions. Why was it necessary in the first place? And were you trained, Jon, to avoid violence in the workplace or to be violent in the office? The second option seems much more useful than the first to us. Anyway, back to Jon's e-mail:

"As with any Microsoft product, I sure wouldn't want version 1 of this thing, since it would likely use Windex on the carpet and then try to vacuum the windows after I ask it to make Windows better. Setting it loose in the kitchen would undoubtedly result in half-baked food like hamburger cookies and oatmeal cheesecake that Microsoft thought were good ideas. If I asked it to do the laundry, I can imagine coming home and finding the robot wearing my underwear on its head. And not because it thought it would be funny."

Mmm, oatmeal cheesecake. But Jon wasn't finished (fortunately, because this is good stuff). He actually sent a whole separate e-mail to say this:

"It would always promise to deliver a delicious dinner by 6:00 p.m. but would usually let its schedule slip until much later. The more interesting of the promised side dishes would have to be cut to make the new deadline. Dinner would have an excessive ad campaign to keep my interest while I'm waiting."

Jon, you've got us shaking here (all four cheeks and a chin, as Cliff Claven once said on "Cheers"). That was fantastic stuff. And we loved David's entry, too. Thanks, guys, and keep it coming.

Any more commands for the Microsoft robot? Send them to [email protected].

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/07/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


December RCP: It's Not What You Know...

It's whether you know the right people in Redmond that can make a huge difference in your success in dealing with Microsoft. And even if you don't know these people personally, you should at least know who they are and what they have going on. (Of course, getting to know them face to face never hurts.) From our December issue, here are 23 execs every partner should be familiar with.

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/07/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Release Candidates Hit the Trail

RC1s of Vista SP1 and Windows Server 2008 are due out this week, and, like Vista, Windows Server is going to lose the dreaded "kill switch" with the 2008 release.

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/06/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Dell Tries To Thaw Channel Ice

Well, here he is again, that smooth-talker wearing an ascot and a smoking jacket and carrying two champagne flutes. He wants to make up. Really, he does. He wants the channel to know that it's real this time -- that he won't go behind your back with that direct-sales model again. He just wants you to listen. He says that he needs you now more than ever.

Dell has a channel program -- a real one, with logos and levels and everything. Oh, it's not a surprise or anything; partners have been raking in money for the direct-sales giant for a while now. But Dell, which has treated the channel like a jilted girlfriend in the past, wants to get serious about working with partners now because it has to. So the company is reaching out to partners, hoping to woo them, promising them that Dell's commitment to them is real.

And it probably is. After all, anybody who follows the technology industry knows that Dell has struggled financially in recent years and that founder Michael Dell is back in the company's driver's seat. Furthermore, it's Dell himself who has his executives turning on the Texas charm to try to lure partners to work with a company that was once considered Public Enemy No. 1 in the channel.

Dell's channel program is pretty comprehensive, as Scott Bekker reports in his story for RCP (which is pretty darn comprehensive, too.) The question doesn't seem to be so much whether Dell is serious about recruiting partners, but rather whether partners will trust the company -- which for so long flaunted its direct-sales model -- enough to work with it. Given the potential profits involved, they probably will.

But it'll take a while for Dell to build relationships in the channel, and it'll be interesting to track the new partner program's success. After all, old wounds don't just heal overnight.

Will you allow Dell to romance you into its partner program? Tell me at [email protected].

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/06/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


December RCP: Readers (Almost) Couldn't Be Happier

The results of the reader survey RCP conducted this past summer (and thanks to all who took part, by the way) are finally in. And the survey says...you're happy! Almost ridiculously happy being Microsoft partners. But there are a few little thorny issues. If you want to find out what they are, click the link. (Come on. You didn't think you were going to get out of visiting the Web site, did you?)

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/06/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


SAP Business ByDesign: Hands Off, Partners

SAP, the big German enterprise resource planning monster, put on a little conference in Boston this week that offered one of the great dessert tables of our era. Seriously, it was epic, offering everything from blueberry cobbler to kids'-party-style cupcakes and fudge. Accustomed to the standard fare of lemon squares and mediocre tiramisu on offer at most conferences, your editor delighted in a sugary mid-afternoon romp. For that, we say danke schön, SAP, and come back to town any time.

Aside from the dessert spectacular, which would've been enough on its own, the SAP Influencer Summit -- the name suggests that somebody must've known that RCPU would be there -- offered an opportunity for SAP to tout the latest version of its hosted customer relationship management offering and brought CEO Henning Kagermann to town for what was (no kidding) billed as a "fireside chat" with the press. That there was no actual fire was somewhat disappointing -- and in fact, the meeting took the form more of a moderately controlled Q&A than that of a "chat."

Still, having covered SAP on and off for years, we've always appreciated the forthrightness of the company's executives, who are much less likely to use platitudes, meaningless fluff lines and burned-out marketing phrases than are their counterparts in Redmond. And while the news surrounding SAP CRM 2007 was interesting (see Barbara Darrow's excellent wrap-up for RCP here), RCPU was especially intrigued by a few of Kagermann's comments.

He said, for instance, that he doesn't see the business intelligence market even being a market in a few years time. (You'll remember that SAP bought BI titan Business Objects not long ago.) BI will just be part of what enterprise software does, Kagermann said, as absorption of BI vendors into bigger companies continues. And while he said that another big BI purchase from SAP wasn't likely in the next year, he wouldn't shut the door to one completely, basically giving a "you never know"-type answer.

Kagermann also quelled speculation that Microsoft and SAP were talking about a merger or acquisition of some sort, flatly denying rumors that he'd been talking to Microsoft about a sale.

But what intrigued us most about Kagermann's conference room Q&A -- actually, fireside chat does sound much better -- were his comments on partner recruitment for SAP's hosted ERP offering, Business ByDesign. The company is recruiting partners to sell the Software-as-a-Service play, but Kagermann doesn't want to hear from consultants or channel players looking to modify or sell add-ons to the system. No, at least for now, SAP is recruiting traditional resellers -- or partners willing to act as traditional resellers -- for Business ByDesign. Kagermann pointed partners and customers in search of customizable mid-market applications to Business All-in-One, SAP's budget, on-premise ERP suite.

"If somebody wants to modify a midsize product, he can buy All-in-One," Kagermann said. "We will not allow modification [of ByDesign]. We want to avoid the cost of ownership getting too high."

So there you go, partners -- resell ByDesign, but whatever you do, don't hope for consulting revenues from it. SAP wants to keep the SaaS service cheap, and consulting fees can get kind of expensive. It's a message that seems to be just the opposite of what Microsoft wants partners to hear. Redmond tells its channel players to find ways to add onto its budding SaaS offerings (including the hosted Dynamics CRM application), but SAP's message (to both partners and customers) is a stern "hands off." (At least for now -- Kagermann did leave the door open to partners eventually doing some consulting work as the product matures.)

And, in a sense, the message makes sense. SAP wants to keep ByDesign simple and inexpensive. In modern parlance, ByDesign is what it is -- and what it's not, or at least not supposed to be, is something that could become very expensive and unwieldy. Since most partners selling ByDesign are probably involved with lots of other aspects of selling and supporting SAP, it's not likely to be a big deal that they won't be able to reap consulting revenues from the on-demand offering. But it is unusual that in an era when pretty much everybody else is telling partners to specialize and develop domain expertise, SAP is encouraging them -- at least with this one product -- to be traditional resellers.

We're guessing -- although we don't know for sure -- that SAP must be offering a pretty sweet compensation deal to ByDesign resellers...possibly including some treats from the Influencer Summit's dessert table. That perk alone would make the whole effort worthwhile.

What experience have you had working with SAP? With ByDesign? What's your take on hosted applications that partners aren't supposed to touch? What was on the best dessert table you ever saw at a trade show or conference? Tell me at [email protected].

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/05/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Reller Lands New Redmond Gig

A thousand apologies from RCPU for not bringing you this story last week, but, in case you missed it, popular former Microsoft Dynamics executive Tami Reller (who, RCPU once speculated, might have been a little too Great Plains for Redmond) has landed herself a plum gig as CFO of Microsoft's Platform & Services division.

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/05/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Microsoft Talks UC Deliverables

Redmond has been talking up its unified communications strategy for a while now, but the industry titan is finally starting to get specific about exactly what tools will comprise its UC offering. RCPU colleague Barbara Darrow has details here.

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/04/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Microsoft Buys Former Exec's Company

Michael Toutonghi is headed back to the Redmond campus, presumably a wealthier -- although maybe not that much wealthier -- man after Microsoft's acquisition of his start-up, WebFives (which, incidentally, is a name that has "dot-com boom" written all over it, even though it's obviously not from that era. No wonder the company struggled.)

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/04/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Report: SMBs Not Sold on Open Source

A new report tells us what we already knew: It's a Microsoft world, at least as far as open source is concerned. This time, The 451 Group (Ray Bradbury fans, perhaps?) took a look at the viability of open source software in the small and midsize business (SMB, of course) space.

And guess what? SMBs aren't so hot on open source. Why? Well, the report says that SMBs don't have big enough IT budgets to make major changes to their Microsoft-dominated systems, and besides that, they can't find the type of expertise they need to run open source systems, anyway -- whereas MCSEs are all over the place. The report also noted that the earth revolves around the sun and that Bill Gates is rich.

Seriously, though, we know that Linux-based servers are making significant inroads into data centers and have been for a while, and we're not anti-open source as far as the concept of open source development goes. (We are not always as fond, however, of the open source "movement" and some of its primary characters.)

But the moral of the story remains the same: It's still a Microsoft world, and it's going to be for at least a while longer. And for Microsoft partners, that's good news.

How much interest in open source do you encounter among your customers? Let me know at [email protected].

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/04/2007 at 1:21 PM1 comments


Boo-Yeah! Stuart Scott Lives

Microsoft's ousted former CIO has turned up at a mortgage lender in Florida. We're actually pretty surprised that a mortgage lender was hiring in the first place.

Posted by Lee Pender on 12/04/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


The Microsoft Robot Is At Your Command

So...normally on Friday, we run reader feedback. But since we haven't had any reader feedback since before Thanksgiving (Thursday of last week, for those of you outside the U.S.), we're going to keep this Friday issue of RCPU fairly short and hopefully somewhat sweet. Don't let us down during this festive season, though -- an e-mail to RCPU (at [email protected]) is the gift that we'll give right back to you in this space next week.

Anyway, we had to smile today at a story out of Japan, where a company called ZMP has developed a two-legged robot that runs on Microsoft robotics software. Now, there's an unfathomable number of jokes we could make about crashes, security flaws and maybe even how the Microsoft robot keeps accusing the Linux robot of stealing all its best tricks, but we'd rather turn the floor over to you.

We'd like to know what you would want your Microsoft robot to do. It can be anything, really -- well, anything fit to print in a family-friendly newsletter, we suppose. Would you want it to get you a cold beverage during the game? Actually figure out licensing terms for virtualization technologies? Develop a coherent SaaS strategy? Redesign the partner program Web site?

The Microsoft robot is at your command. Send your instructions to [email protected].

Posted by Lee Pender on 11/30/2007 at 1:21 PM0 comments


Subscribe on YouTube