ITC Bars Motorola Mobile Devices That Infringe Microsoft Patent

The U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) determined today that Motorola Mobility Inc. has violated Microsoft's intellectual property.

The decision, which concerns a meeting scheduling software patent, could be appealed. However, the court noted (PDF) that it has issued an exclusion order that prohibits the import of Motorola mobile products that use the technology. The technology is associated with the use of the Android mobile operating system and is associated with Microsoft ActiveSync technology, according to an announcement issued by a Microsoft spokesperson.

The court had originally considered Microsoft's contentions about a year-and-a-half ago that nine of its patents were infringed by Motorola. Those contentions were reduced to one charge, with Motorola found to have infringed on a patent for "Generating meeting requests and group scheduling from a mobile device" (Patent No. 6,370,566).

At this point, Motorola Mobility could pay royalties to license the technology from Microsoft or it could remove the technology from its U.S. imports. In any case, the ITC has set a penalty. Motorola has to "post a bond set at a reasonable royalty rate in the amount of $0.33 per device" while the case undergoes ITC "presidential review."

An attorney for Microsoft claimed that the suit was brought in the first place because Motorola had refused to renew a licensing agreement.

    "Microsoft sued Motorola in the ITC only after Motorola chose to refuse Microsoft's efforts to renew a patent license for well over a year," said David Howard, corporate vice president and deputy general counsel at Microsoft, in a released statement. "We're pleased the full Commission agreed that Motorola has infringed Microsoft's intellectual property, and we hope that now Motorola will be willing to join the vast majority of Android device makers selling phones in the US by taking a license to our patents."

Microsoft claims that about 70 percent of original equipment manufacturers have signed agreements on using its intellectual property alleged to be used in Android. Motorola is one of the few such manufacturers to have taken the matter to court.

The two companies still have other legal actions pending. An unrelated case in Germany found Microsoft to be the intellectual property offender with its Exchange ActiveSync technology, but that case is getting a second look. The two companies also are fighting over the cost of essential patents royalties in yet another case.

One backdrop to these legal actions is intense competition in the mobile operating systems markets. Microsoft and Apple have both claimed that the leading mobile OS, the Linux-based Android, violates their intellectual property. Google, which fostered Android and gives it to equipment manufacturers royalty free, is currently seeking final regulatory approvals to buy Motorola Mobility. That purchase is designed, in part, to bolster Google's collection of patents for legal defensive purposes.

About the Author

Kurt Mackie is online news editor for the 1105 Enterprise Computing Group.

comments powered by Disqus

Reader Comments:

Sun, Feb 2, 2014

At LinkedIQ we've installed Google Apps for svreeal small and mid-size businesses that can't stop raving about the increased productivity they're experiencing from this service. I personally facilitate the operations of two internet companies, both of which rely on Google Apps for collaboration. And, yes, I am happy. [url=]zmqvnlzw[/url] [link=]tzlzpgc[/link]

Sun, Jan 19, 2014

My Motorola i1 is defective, the phone can not read the micro SD Card. I can't take pics, vids or save http://e DOT on it. I sent in to be repaired, it was sent back not repaired. I sent it in again an it is take too long. No one logs in the status. Their phones fail often. Has not been goods products for me.

Sat, Jan 18, 2014

Hey, I just came across this site that is suodpseply giving away a number of Motorola Droid's, ofcourse the chance of getting one is small since there must be tons of people signing up for this, but anyway, I signed up and I'm hoping to be one of the lucky ones. It's free and takes like 30 seconds so I thought why not. My brother even joined the contest and he already owns a Droid. Check it out!bizoppofferDOTcom/x/0/962/4434/

Sat, May 19, 2012 symbolset

Microsoft wanted $15 per device, for all Moto Android devices. Now Moto has to take out one feature almost nobody uses (requesting meetings in Exchange), and only has to pay 33 cents per device until the feature is taken out - which has now probably already been done. They might have to pay One MILLION dollars. This is not a big problem for Moto. It's a bigger problem for Microsoft, who WANTS BYOD devices to connect to Exchange. Talk about shooting yourself in the foot. In return Microsoft goes to global war with 100-year old technology pioneer Motorola Mobility with their 12,000 patents. Motorola invented the commercial mobile phone. Motorola's counterstrike involves a ban on Windows, XBox and maybe Windows Phone in all of Europe. It's a global war with current actions in 14 countries. Way to go Microsoft! Keep up the good fight!

Add Your Comment Now:

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Please type the letters/numbers you see above

Redmond Tech Watch

Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.