In-Depth

The Xbox Files

Is Microsoft's wonder toy the next step in the evolution of the PC?


Your work as an IT professional never ends. When you're not poking your head behind a patch panel, tackling a list of troubleshooting tickets, or translating napkin drawings into a real project, you've opted to spend some of your free time nosing through resource kits, exam guides and other resources to bone up on a Microsoft exam. Then, some of you have families that take up what time is left. With the few moments that remain after all that, why would you choose to play video games?

Past history dictates that I should not own another gaming system. I say this based on my propensity to remain enraptured for hours into the early morning, trying to attain one more conquest, rescue or kill. I resisted up until a few weeks ago. With my will broken, I went online and purchased a Microsoft Xbox. It's no secret that Microsoft's hyped up entry into the video gaming niche competes directly with Sony PlayStation 2 and Nintendo GameCube, but the offer was put in front of me to explore the Xbox's potential as a networked, broadband-ready home computing device. That the Xbox's innards are on par with my circa-1997 home PC and has potential for being customized is worth exploring even further.

The Beast from Within
The basic Xbox comes with the typical components you'll find on its competitors: a console with a media tray, a controller and RCA-style cables for hooking up the unit directly to a TV. The console has slots for four controllers on the front of the unit, plus a 10/100 Ethernet port slot on the back of the unit to accommodate broadband access. Microsoft just completed successful beta trials of the Xbox Live service, which the company plans to launch this summer.

Console, top and back
Figure 1. Xbox console, back and top-front. The back view shows the 10/100 Ethernet port to the right, for broadband-ready gaming, due later this summer.

Inside the unit is a 733MHz Pentium III paired with a 233MHz nVidia graphics processor chip; 64MB RAM; a DVD drive, and an 8GB hard drive. Only about two gigs are taken up by the machine's applications and processing, which leaves nearly 6GB for saving game progress. You can save your game progress and make it portable using an optional memory unit, which slips into one of two slots on the front of the controllers. Table 1 shows the configuration of the Xbox, compared to other gaming systems and a typical PC. Other optional accessories include an HDTV cable, wheel/foot pedal controller, and DVD playback unit.

Table 1. Comparing a home PC to the top three gaming consoles.
What
You Get
Home PC(a)
Xbox(b)
Sony PlayStation 2(b)
Nintendo GameCube(b)
CPU; graphics Pentium III; ATI graphics chip 733 MHz Pentium III; 233 MHz nVidia 294.912 MHz; 147.456 MHz graphics synthesizer 485MHz Power PC; 162 MHz ATI graphics chip
Memory; memory card 64MB, 3 expansion slots 64MB; 2 expansion slots on controller 32MB; 1 memory card slot on controller 40MB; 1 expansion slot on controller
Hard Disk Yes Yes No No
Drive formats 3.5-inch disk; 16x CDROM-burner DVD/CD player capabilities DVD/CD player capabilities Mini-DVD
Input/Output Keyboard, mouse, joystick (bought separately); USB connector; NIC Controller (max: 4); wheel; 10/100 Ethernet port Controller (max 2, with multi-tap); USB connector (2); IEEE 1394 connector; Optical Out; wheel Controller (max: 4); serial port (2); parallel port
Broadband support Yes (via NIC) Yes (available late summer 2002) Yes (available late summer 2002) Yes (no date for availability of service)
Price (U.S. retail) Approx. $800 (purchased in 1997; CPU, keyboard, mouse, monitor, cables and Windows, Microsoft Office, and other assorted software applications); $35 (approx. price in 1997; Duke Nuke'm); $20 (Myst) $299 (console, 1 controller, cables); $49.99 (Munch's Odyssey) $299 (console, 1 controller, cables); $49.99 (Grand Theft Auto) $299 (console, 1 controller, cables); $49.99 (Resident Evil)
a. This is my circa-1997 PC at home. This might not be your PC, but then again I only make an editor's wage. Prices are shown circa 1997; a comparably equipped 2002 PC for approx. $800 might include an Athlon XP Processor, 256MB RAM, 40GB hard drive, and DVD-ROM.
b. Sources: Microsoft, Sony, Nintendo

Looks Can Be Deceiving
While the Xbox closely resembles a PC in many ways, a Microsoft spokesperson dismissed this comparison emphatically: "It's first and foremost a gaming console." What makes the Xbox slightly better is that it actually boots up and load games quickly—PCs still can't do that. Xbox isn't a PC nor is it intended to replace one, but, then again, a shoe is not a hammer.

Oddworld
Figure 2. Abe the wage slave facing another day at the office (from Oddworld: Munch's Oddyssey)

All of this sophisticated hardware in such a small case for a mere $299 U.S. retail hasn't gone unnoticed by folks prone to attempt a reverse-engineer of the Xbox's mystery operating system (rumored to be a stripped down Windows 2000 kernel) and security-hardened hard drive so that it can be turned into an inexpensive PC. For one thing, the Xbox hard drive isn't so security hardened as to be impenetrable. One Xbox feature lets you copy music tracks from your favorite CDs to the hard drive, which means the potential for loading software and applications exists.

Supersize It

If Xbox isn't the evolution of the inexpensive PC, perhaps the rumored HomeStation is. This, according to Prudential Securities analyst Hans Mosesmann, as reported in EBN.com. In an article entitled "Microsoft reported to ready all-in-one home gateway," Bruce Gain reports that Mosesmann sees hints in Microsoft's partnerships at a convergence of technologies that may evolve into HomeStation, a PC-type unit that combines traditional computing functions with gaming, a high-end audio receiver, superior graphics, and broadband capabilities. Asked to verify Mosesmann's findings, a Microsoft spokesperson says that the rumor is "erroneous." Nonetheless, Mosesmann is onto something: a PC as inexpensive and as easy to set up and use as a gaming console for your average consumer. If Microsoft does as he predicts, perhaps "a HomeStation in every living room" might become the new Microsoft mantra.

To read the story, go to http://www.ebnonline.com/digest/story/
OEG20020116S0044
. ( A similar story appears at Tech Live; see "Xbox Version 2.0?" at http://www.techtv.com/news/computing/story/
0,25195,3369110,00.html
.)

A search of newsgroups already shows dozens of messages with hackers hinting at cracking open the unit and going even further—naturally, in violation of any end user license agreement and software laws. Plans include configuring a controller port for a keyboard or replacing the operating system with Linux. It's lots of work, but someone's pioneering efforts can pave the way to a more simplified, repeatable process. (No, I didn't cook up this crazy idea in my head. I found one particular thread discussing such a scenario at microsoft.public.xbox newsgroup—your own research might turn up dozens more.)

Even more useful is the idea of networking beyond games. The Xbox's Ethernet port is useless at the moment, but Microsoft plans to render networked, multi-user gaming revenue from it in late summer. Networked games aren't some new Microsoft innovation, just an outgrowth of existing networked PC gaming. In much the same way that PCs can be peer networked, there exists the potential of peer networking dozens or hundreds of reengineered Xboxes, at a much lower cost per unit than even cheap Pentium III-based PCs.

The Xbox as inexpensive Linux box or peered networking machines are mythical ideas at the moment. Another one is that Microsoft will make strides in future versions to make it resemble a PC functionally. Microsoft has denied media reports suggesting that the company has plans in the works to do so (see "Supersize It").

Additional Information

My Internet-based research has turned up no enterprising company with the innovation to create a game that might help MCP candidates prepare for exams or IT wannabes to understand subnetting. That being the case, here some less helpful resources that will make your gaming experience more productive:

Okay, Just One More Level
Microsoft Xbox, plain and simple, is a well-designed, easy-to-set-up gaming console that lacks depth in its game offerings. With just one game, I find that I'm easily addicted and have even reassessed my TV viewing habits to include at least an hour or two on the Xbox. The gaming niche has room enough for another competitor, it seems. But there's potential inside the box, if Microsoft can be nudged to turn it into an affordable, networked computer for the masses.

comments powered by Disqus

Reader Comments:

Thu, Jul 25, 2002 josh dickweed land

sod off you twat !

Thu, Jul 25, 2002 corey iowa

shit

Thu, Jul 25, 2002 corey iowa

shit

Thu, Jul 25, 2002 Anonymous Anonymous

shit

Wed, Jul 10, 2002 tordavis San Diego

Wow, Mike sure can churn out those articles. This one was top notch! What can I say, I bought an Xbox after reading it.

Thu, Jun 13, 2002 syneptody towson, maryland USA

info in this article is good. however, readers should be aware of xbox-linux.org which is now an official organization actively developing a linux kernel for the xbox shell. stable kernels have already been developed and device drivers are in the works. i support all creatures who respect the xbox as a true product innovation!

Sun, Jun 9, 2002 Rayudu Addagarla Louisville ,KY ,USA

a good article about XBox and comparision of the other two competetors

Fri, May 24, 2002 Sascha Cologne, Germany

I like the comparison table.

Fri, May 17, 2002 Mike Wood Chester, Virginia

Best there is!!!!

Wed, May 15, 2002 Anonymous Anonymous

This is one of the most interestging off topic articles in a long time

Tue, May 14, 2002 Anonymous Anonymous

Very good

Add Your Comment Now:

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above

Redmond Tech Watch

Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.