EU Threatens New Fines Against Microsoft
Microsoft is asking rivals to pay too much for information that can help software interoperate, claims European Union commissioner.
(Brussels, Belgium) The European Union escalated its trans-Atlantic fight
with Microsoft Corp. on Thursday, threatening new multimillion fines against
the software maker over claims it is asking rivals to pay too much for
information that would help their servers work with Windows.
In response, Microsoft charged that the treatment it received from the
EU is unprecedented and harmed Europe's efforts to become a thriving high-tech
The EU said the software maker could face daily fines as high as 3 million
euros ($4 million), and accused Microsoft of protecting its own interests
by setting unreasonable prices for the "complete and accurate"
documentation competitors would need to build products that interoperate
with Windows PCs and servers.
In a so-called "statement of objections" released Thursday,
the EU's executive Commission rejected 1,500 pages of documents Microsoft
submitted to back up its pricing.
"I am therefore again obliged to take formal measures to ensure
that Microsoft complies with its obligations," EU Antitrust Commissioner
Neelie Kroes said in a statement.
Microsoft General Counsel Brad Smith responded that Microsoft had asked
for feedback on its pricing proposals and documentation half a year ago,
and only Thursday received a reply thinly veiled in a threat.
"We're disappointed that this feedback is coming six months later
and in its present form," said Smith during a telephone conference.
"You cannot reach an agreement if you are just talking to yourself."
He added "the findings appear to be an attempt to regulate the pricing
of our intellectual property rights on a global basis" something
which would go beyond the jurisdiction of the European Union.
This is not the first time EU regulators threatened fines to push Microsoft
to comply with its 2004 antitrust ruling, in which it found the company
broke competition laws and abused its dominant market position.
Besides the record 497 million euro ($613 million) fine it imposed at
the time of the ruling, the EU levied a 280.5 million euro ($371 million)
fine last summer, saying Microsoft did not supply complete interoperability
Microsoft has reached licensing agreements with several of the companies
that originally took issue with the software maker's practices and pricing,
including Sun Microsystems Inc. and Novell Inc.
But the company still faces pressure in Europe from open-source software
companies that want to use its technology, said Matt Rosoff, an analyst
for Directions on Microsoft, an independent research group.
"Microsoft has a lot of problems with allowing its intellectual
property to be incorporated into an open-source product," which may
be part of the reason the issue has not yet been resolved, Rosoff said
in an interview.
The EU said Thursday that three years after the landmark antitrust ruling,
the U.S. software company was still using heavy-handed tactics to choke
rivals in the software sector, but did not name any specific competitors.
"This is a company which apparently does not like to have to conform
with antitrust decisions," said EU Commission spokesman Jonathan
Smith said the company has had better back-and-forth negotiations "in
other capitals, in other countries and that is what we need in Brussels
if Europe is going to have an economy that genuinely fosters technology
Ronald Cass, chairman of the Washington-based Center for the Rule of
Law, said the EU "has taken another step toward turning successful
businesses into regulated utilities."
"The Commission's new effort, if pursued, will undermine innovation
and take Europe further away from the sort of predictable, stable, sensible
legal rules that define the rule of law," Cass said.
The EU insisted it did not want to douse innovation.
"The Commission does not want Microsoft to have to give away the
fruits of its research for free," said Todd. "Microsoft is perfectly
entitled to a fair share of the results of its innovation. However, the
Commission decision does not allow Microsoft to charge for interoperability
information based on its own dominant position in the PC software market."
The company has four weeks to reply to the Commission's preliminary finding.
Microsoft is challenging the EU's 2004 antitrust ruling _ which resulted
in the order to share code and information with rivals at reasonable prices
_ at the EU's Court of First Instance. A decision is expected sometime
In the meantime, said Rosoff, the Directions on Microsoft analyst, "I
suspect Microsoft will lower its prices to avoid paying the fines."
AP Business Writer Jessica Mintz in Seattle contributed to this report.